is forex hallal???

salam friends .. .ap sub se ik important question puchna tha i know ye pehly b question pucha ja chuka ha but answer satisfied nae hain . ..
k kya ye online forex trading islam me halal ha q k me ne kafi logon se suna aur search b ki k ye margin k sath trading haram hoti(gambling aur riba) ha ap kya kahen gy is k bary me plzzzz help me
aur try karen k jis k pas iski better reason ha ho answer kary .. . ..

may to is ko halal he samjhti hu wo is vja say k is may sood nai hai jis ko aap ribba keh ray ho yeh phir gambling b nai hai ager aap ko forex ki proper study hai aap ager use may mobile purchase karo gy to koshish karo gy ko sasta mily and jb becho gy to us ko mhenga bechny k to hum b currencies isi base pay purchase wegara kerty hain hum loss b bear kerty hain so my point of view is its halal baqi jo merzi jo kahy

margin kay sath to kuch nahi kaha ja sakta hay bai is liay main to jab tak is baray main confirm nahi ker layti main kuch nahi keh sakti,wasay apki bat sun kay ye matter kafi serious ho gya hay.albta margin kay ilawa to confirm hallal hay.

mery bhai forex pe log hallal bhe kam krty han or hram bhe jo hallal kam krty han fida hota han jo haram kam krty han vho loss he krty han hamen cha he ya ky ham is men essy ho ky kam kryn or ache net ky sath kam kren

mai to yahi kahun ga k insta forex ik bussiness hai or bussiness hallal hota hai or is main kisi kism ka sood nai hai is liye ye hallal hai kiun k agr hm apni aam zindagi main dekhin to hm koi b cheez sell karty hain to hmari yahi koshish hoti hai k ye achy se achy paisun main sell ho jai or jab koi cheez buy karni hoti hai to tab hmari yahi koshish hoti hai k hmain sasti mil jayi or is main b yahi hisab hai

Dear friend forex aik hilal rozgar ha, har banday k lie jo har banda apny ghar bith k aik acha profit gain kr sagta ha, apne mehnat say jo kam kr jata ha wo aik hilal rozgar ha.

bhai jan meri nazar ma tu forex k 1 hala business ha kion k is business ma loss and profit sath sath ha after that hum pora pora din market ko watch ker k technical analysis ker k trade ker kfir ja ker kahin profit lyty han us k bad hum daily post per k pora month kam ker k bonus lyty hna fir hum ja ker us per trading ker paty han

jo brother/sister halal keh rahy hain aur reason ye dy rahy hain k "ye ik business ha aur business halal hota ha" to ye koe reason nae ha. .. .. .
ap jahan b dekh lain ye apko mily ga k margin k sath koe b business halal nae ha. .. ..me khud ye kam kar raha hun but jb se is bat ka pta chala ha ik ajeb si becheni lagi hui ha is liye pucha ha ap se. .. .

Bro i think Forex ma swap walay account haram hoty hian or Swap Free (Islamic Account) halal hoty hian hope this will helps

g i know margin k bagair halal ha but yahan asal problem e margin ka ha

my brother may samjtha ho k froex halal hay.... haram kam to wo hotah hy k ham ksi galat tareqay say dosro ki haq talfi karay and najaiz zarai ka istimal karay.. aur forux to haram ho nh skta q k is me hamm apni mahnat say trading karaty hai....

sir main is kam ko halal samajhta hon kiyon kay aisa kam jis main humain loss ya profit dono possibilities shamil hon or is main hamari effort bhi ho or us main koi SOOD shamil naho to woh halal hai is liya donot worry about this .

Dear friend ji haan forex trading aik bohat acha online business hai aur yeh bilkul halal hai kiyunke hum iss mein investment karkey currencies per trading kertay hein aur apna profit hasil kertay hein.

mere khayal se forex halal hai kyun kay iss main profit loss dono hotay hain iss liye humain chahye kay pahlay kisi mufti ya ALim e deen se knowledge hasil karain iss work kay baray mai tah kay koi bhi issue na rahay aur misconcept create na ho sakay

g han forex hallal hi hay q k is me apki aik way say trading me mahnat hi hoti hai.... and har wo kamm hallal hai jis me inasan ki mahnat include ho..